CC: http://www.afropoets.net/nikkigiovanni18.html
Giovanni uses universal gender roles, descriptive words and
problems to describe stereotypes. Since the title of the poem is Crutches,
Giovanni suggest that the poem would mean supporting someone or that something
is saving the targeted group of people of person. The tone of the poem, Crutches, is judgmental to express
her critical opinion and sometimes shifts to condescension to express her feeling of superiority.
As the reader, we would guess that Giovanni is the speaker, based on Giovanni's
feminist perspective. The pattern of the poem is ironically perfect and
organized stanzas. Giovanni still expresses her poems in free-verse format.
Giovanni opens the poem with, "it's not the crutches
we decry, it's the need to move forward, though we haven't the strength". Giovanni
suggests that as a person or a group of people, it is the need to advance
and develop, but we lack strength and perseverance. Giovanni then shifts the
tone of the poem as judgmental when she says, "women
aren't suppose to be strong so they develop social smiles and secret drinking
problems and female lovers whom they never touch except in dreams." Giovanni
suggests that women are supposes to be gentle and not strong. This also
suggests that women smile to hide their emotion. In society, the gender role of
a woman is to be gentle and to basically be a perfect wife. To the reader, that
stanza expresses the group of people are hurting themselves by trying to be
accepted in the society by social stereotypes. Giovanni makes another stereotype
about woman when she says, "and female lovers whom
they never touch except in dreams". This expresses that women
drink to hide their troubles and to tell themselves that they are inferior and
less strong than men. Giovanni makes a judgmental remark when shifting the
focus on another group of people, which are men. She says, "men are suppose to be strong, so they
have heart attacks and develop other women who don't know their weaknesses and
hide their fears behind male lovers." Giovanni suggest that
men have heart attacks. Heart attacks are known to be a disease of the athletes
or people who have a lot of stress like work, which is suggesting that men are
over-achievers. This is because men are seen in society as strong and not weak.
This also suggests that men might need comfort and support to lessen their
heart form being strained. Giovanni ends with the poem to declare that each
group of people should not want to conform in society.
I like your focus on gender roles in the poem. Why do you think Giovanni focuses on both men and women and not race, specifically, like she does in her other poems? What could she be saying about the use of and/or need of crutches? In your discussion of the tone of the poem, what leads you to say that Giovanni expresses a "feeling of superiority"?
ReplyDelete